Imagine a glossy photo of a blonde woman with eyes the colour of precious aquamarines and
skin as translucent as Royal Doulton china. Look at the pride and confidence contained in
her sweet smile. This Yorkshire lass is a woman of strength, energy, and generosity. In
her hands, she holds the gift of healing; a gift she freely gives to others.
Now, imagine that photo being torn in half. No matter how hard one tries to repair it,
the damage is transparently obvious; this woman cannot be put back together again. Jean
Smith, at 54, has irreversible damage to her frontal and temporal lobes.
This case is a tragedy emotionally, psychologically, physically and financially. Jean's
husband, James, had to sell all her assets to qualify for Medicare. He had to hire lawyers:
one to make him Jean's guardian, and one to fight Social Security's attempt to take his
40lK. After surviving this conflict, James realized that the long-term care facility was
a misnomer, since Jean soon became semi-comatose. Consequently, he has had to hire
malpractice lawyers who are fighting to fund the cost of Jean's home care. Although James
is her primary caregiver, he must also work full-time, in the business world, to support
them. Jean is in adult day care, because neither the insurance company, nor social
services, will pay for home nursing.
Yet, as black and heavy as this nightmare has been for the whole family, spangles of sun
have danced their way through to provide some respite. The friends of Jean Smith had a
fundraiser that helped offset the cost of home care, and the response was overwhelming.
They raised $23,000 that has helped with the cost of day care. Unfortunately, as this
fund dwindles the stress level starts to rise, and the nightmare continues. Jean has been
home for 8 mos. now and goes to Adult Day Care. She is totally dependent.
The nightmare began during Easter weekend 1999, when Jean complained about an infection.
She thought the cause of the infection was antibiotics administered to fight bronchitis.
Jean's disease began with flu-like symptoms of fatigue, fever, and vomiting which were then
followed by loss of memory, anxiety, and agitation. It was this change in behavior that
alarmed her daughter and husband. I knew my mom hadn't felt well over the weekend so I said,
"Mom, do you need a doctor?" She replied, "Yes." I called her longtime doctor from
Washington, D.C. and he told me she had called him and he asked if she'd been drinking.
She said, "No", so he told her to go to the hospital.
In the meantime, my husband called my stepfather and told him to get home. My
mom had already driven herself to the local hospital, Anne Arundel Medical Center
by the time I called her. She was combative and pulled the IV's out and said she
was going home. The doctors thought she had had a mini stroke after they checked the cat scan. They told
my stepfather he could keep her there overnight for observation, but mom was so insistent
on going home, my stepfather agreed to let her. I was upset and told mom so. She said,
she'd be okay. The following day, I called her doctor again and told him what happened.
He said to either get her back to the hospital or call a Neurologist. After getting in
touch with a less than nice person at the hospital, I quickly found a neurologist locally
who agreed to see her that day. I just wanted to get mom help.
By Sunday, she had a 101 fever and felt she should go to hospital. But once there,
she decided to go home with my stepfather. They reside in Annapolis, MD. The following
day, she convinced my stepfather to go to work and she'd call him if she needed him.
On Tuesday, my stepfather, Jim took mom to the Neurologist. The neurologist did not
schedule an MRI until the following day. However, when I finally arrived at mom's house,
I knew things were wrong. I called the neurologist late that night and said I thought mom
should go to hospital. He asked if she had a headache and I told him I didn't know, she
couldn't really tell me. He said to just check her every hour and take her for an MRI
early in the morning. We did. By then, my mom got dressed and then put one of stepfather's
shirts over her own. She was very sleepy and kept saying as we drove her to MRI, "This is
crazy, ridiculous." When we got there, mom could not sign her name initially, I just
kept crying.
Things were not right. Afterwards, we rushed the MRI to the neurologist who announced to
us that mom had stroke to left side of brain and she needed to be admitted to hospital. We
took her to Anne Arundel Medical Center. By now mom was so out of it. She did however,
say to me, "Are you going to be okay, you're my best friend", before she became almost
unconscious. For the next 6 days my mom lay in a hospital being treated with heparin for
a stroke. We kept asking why she had a stroke and the doctors weren't sure, saying
"maybe it was high blood pressure or cholesterol", but her doctor in DC didn't think they
were that high. I did ask the neurologist if he checked mom for meningitis or encephalitis
and he said he did not find it necessary. I took him for his word. I had no idea
what either of those things were and did not have access to a computer. I was just in
shock.
We spent every night at the hospital the first week. Jean had to be put in restraints the
first night when she said she wanted to go home. From there on, we just wanted to get Jean
out of this hospital and to rehab. So on Monday, we went to the National Rehab hospital
in Washington, DC. They said she was aphasic, etc. I told them her voice had become
hoarse. They did another catscan but didn't see any more damage. By Wednesday, an
occupational therapist noticed mom was having a seizure. She was sent to the adjoining
Washington Hospital Center where immediately they did an MRI and lumbar puncture (had
never been done). They told us they believed mom had encephalitis and started her on
acyclovir, but this was 8 days after mom had been admitted to hospital and 13 days after
symptoms of flu had begun. Not good. She was on acyclovir for 3 weeks and was bedridden
and only slept a lot. I felt she was in a semi-coma. The doctor would have to tap her
chest to get her attention sometimes. My mom spent 7 mos. in a sub-accute/nursing facility
before we could actually get her home or into rehab. I tried diligently to get her back
into inpatient rehab but all facilities I tried said she was not following enough simple
commands. My stepfather had to continue working.
Jean's mind started to deteriorate rapidly: her memory was chaotic, her speech was
confused, and she no longer recognized her family. Even after admittance to the hospital
two days later, and an MRI, the neurologist insisted that she had suffered a stroke to
the left side of the brain. Not only was she treated for six days with heparin (a blood
thinner) instead of Acyclovir (a drug that fights the symptoms of this disease), the
neurologist considered a spinal tap to be unnecessary. Jean's daughter asked if perhaps
she should have a spinal tap to rule out meningitis and encephalitis, to which the doctor
answered in the negative. Later we discovered that, in suspected cases of encephalitis,
a lumbar puncture (spinal tap) should be taken immediately and a sample sent to a virus
laboratory for examination by PCR (polymerase chain reaction). According to Dr. Graham
Cleator "a definitive aetiological diagnosis can be produced within a matter of hours,
and an accurate diagnosis is possible on the first day or two of neurological illness i.e.
when the patient may only be showing minimal symptoms." Although her encephalitis is
considered rare, it is also a textbook case (all her symptoms are spelled out on the
internet).
Because the Anne Arundel Medical Center never performed the lumbar puncture, and
her case was misdiagnosed, Jean spent six days at this facility without the benefit of
acyclovir, a drug that is central to the treatment of herpes simplex encephalitis.
Thus, after eight days Jean, wearing a catheter, was transferred to the National
Rehab Centre in Washington, D.C. That evening she suffered a seizure and was rushed to
the Washington Hospital Centre. The emergency room doctor immediately consulted with a
neurologist and an infectious disease specialist who was shocked to discover that a spinal
tap had never been taken. Once they assembled all the clinical data (including an MRI
and a lumbar puncture), they quickly determined that Jean had a rare form of encephalitis
- herpes simplex. Sadly, because Jean had not received the proper treatment, she suffered
bilateral damage to frontal and temporal lobes.
During her stay in the hospital, Jean had three infections, suffered weeks of
horrible diarrhea, and had a clot removed from her lung. Three months later, when she
was transferred to a longterm care facility, she could not walk or talk and
was totally dependent on others for her care. The insurance company denied requests for
both home care and inpatient rehab at Johns Hopkins Hospital (this rehabilitation was
recommended by the neuropsychiatrist). It is unfortunate that so many long-term care
facilities are understaffed and overworked. Jean was a victim of this impoverished care
and continued to deteriorate. Her physical therapists were her husband and daughter.
Because of the friends of Jean Smith and their overwhelming generosity, her husband finally succeeded in moving her home.
At home, Jean was under the care of a home aide. Jean became more lethargic and less
inclined to follow simple directions. It was determined that Jean would make better
progress in an Adult Day Care Center. Because Jean's neurological problems cause her to
put everything in her mouth, and to roam constantly, this center could not adequately
meet Jean's needs. Consequently, James found another center in Annapolis that Jean
attends whilst James is at work. Jean continues to see a neuropsychiatrist once a month
to determine what medicines may improve her condition. She has been on several
anti-depressants and anti-psychotic medicines, but there appears to be no improvement.
Moreover, because Jean cannot communicate, no one can determine if they help or hinder.
She continues to be confused, frustrated, and angry and her memory is limited.
Additionally, she cannot use her right arm, she has periodic moments of lucidity, she
sometimes yells, and she is totally dependent on her husband for her daily care.
My stepfather did get mom walking again with no real help from the therapists. They would
give up very easy. Mom did go to Center for Neuro Rehab for a month or so on outpatient
basis but that was discontinued because they could not prove to insurance co. that mom was
making enough progress. Mom sees a neuropsychiatrist at John's Hopkins every other mo.
and we try different meds to help her possibly focus and not be so anxious. Nothing really
seems to work much. She is incontinent. She speaks some and but does appear to be aphasic
and can't name objects. She keeps saying she wants to go home, even though she is home.
Since this tragedy, we have discovered many other Encephalitis victims in this area.
Fortunately, they received immediate proper care, and have resumed a normal life. However,
Jean will never be able to climb out of her chaotic hell. She will never be able to give
fun dinner parties. She will never be able to understand how generous her friends have
been. She will never be able to share insights with her daughter Jale. She will never be
able to have late night tête-à-têtes with her husband James. She will never be able to have
grandmotherly conversations with her adorable granddaughters, Amanda and Sydney. My mom
loved her grandchildren so much and it pains me that they're starting to forget all the
times she cared and played with them. I love my mom very much. I'm an only child. I
know that my stepfather has put his life on hold and is very optimistic for mom. He
doesn't give up hope and he looks to the future whereas I keep playing the early events
over and over again in my mind hoping to change what has happened.
We've been told she has dementia. She tends to put things to her mouth that are not
edible. She can eat on her own but tends to use her hands. She looks suspicious, scared
and anxious a lot. Screams out sometimes. Every once in awhile, we'll see the real Jean
peak out and say, "I love you, etc" She seems to speak best on phone but is anxious
to get off, maybe so you can't tell her full disability. At any rate, I love my mom
very much and I'm so sorry that all this has happened to her and we couldn't have gotten
her a spinal tap and on acyclovir right away. My mom feels she needs to be somewhere all
the time, but not sure where. Her memory is minute to minute. Therefore, she knows
something is wrong but forgets what has happened to her. I called her the other day and
asked how she was and she said, "Everything is wacko." It sure is. What I've learned
from all this is that I should never take anyone for granted
Jean's story is important in that it may help others who contract this disease. If the general public is informed of the symptoms, and the medical staff is made aware of the warning signs, perhaps Jean's suffering will serve a purpose.
Sincerely,